EU & Diplomacy

European Court of Human Rights gives Serbia until 14 January 2027 to respond on Vučić pardons

European Court of Human Rights gives Serbia until 14 January 2027 to respond on Vučić pardonsFoto: Pexels

The European Court of Human Rights has asked Serbia to respond by 14 January 2027 to two applications challenging pardons issued by former President Aleksandar Vučić to people who attacked students during 2025 protests.

  • Five pardon decrees were issued by Vučić on the last day of his term.
  • One case involves activists from Novi Sad who attacked students with baseball bats in January 2025, causing serious injuries.
  • The second case concerns a woman who hit a female student with her car during a 2025 demonstration.
  • The court is examining a possible violation of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits torture and inhuman or degrading treatment.
  • Constitutional appeals are pending in Serbia, and the court has not yet ruled on the merits of the case.

The European Court of Human Rights has asked the Government of Serbia to respond by 14 January 2027 to two applications concerning pardons granted by former President Aleksandar Vučić to people accused of attacking students during protests in 2025.

The applications relate to five pardon decrees that Vučić issued on the last day of his term. The first concerns a group of activists from Novi Sad who attacked students with baseball bats in January 2025 and caused serious bodily injuries. The second concerns a woman who hit a female student with her car during one of the 2025 demonstrations.

Who filed the applications

Both applications were submitted by the Belgrade Centre for Human Rights together with lawyers representing three injured parties. Criminal proceedings in the Novi Sad and Belgrade cases were stopped after the pardons were issued.

Vladica Ilić of the Belgrade Centre for Human Rights told N1 that the court's notification to the government is a procedural step. After Serbia submits its observations in mid-January, the applicants will be able to reply.

Issues before the court

According to Ilić, the court has raised the question of a possible violation of Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights. This provision protects physical and psychological integrity and prohibits torture and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.

The court has also asked whether the applicants could have used any domestic legal remedies before turning to Strasbourg. Ilić said constitutional appeals had already been filed with Serbia's Constitutional Court, together with the victims' lawyers, but the court has not yet ruled on them.

In the next phase, the legal team will have to show that domestic remedies were ineffective. That will determine whether the Strasbourg court examines the merits, meaning whether pardoning the suspects violated the victims' rights.

Ilić's assessment

Ilić said it is disappointing that international bodies act faster than domestic institutions in cases involving serious human rights concerns. He argued that the victims' rights were violated and that people who suffered grave injuries have a right to justice, including punishment of those responsible and not only financial compensation.

He added that if the court finds a breach of the Convention, the state will be declared responsible. The court has not yet taken any decision on the merits. For related coverage, see the N1 debate on the Vučić pardons for 49 people.

The next concrete step is the government's written response, due by 14 January 2027.

Frequently asked questions

Who filed the applications with the European Court of Human Rights?

Both applications were submitted by the Belgrade Centre for Human Rights together with lawyers representing three injured parties.

What is the deadline for Serbia's response to the court?

The Government of Serbia must submit its written response by 14 January 2027. After that, the applicants will be able to reply.

Which article of the European Convention on Human Rights is at issue?

The court is examining a possible violation of Article 3, which protects physical and psychological integrity and prohibits torture and inhuman or degrading treatment.

Why did the applicants turn to Strasbourg?

Constitutional appeals were filed in Serbia, but the Constitutional Court has not yet ruled on them. The court also asks whether domestic remedies were available and effective before applicants approached Strasbourg.